When we think about high performers, there’s often an assumption that their success is tied directly to an innate ability to manage pressure and thrive in stressful environments. Yet, behind that glossy exterior, many top achievers grapple with a type of anxiety that is rarely talked about: performance anxiety. It’s an affliction that can hold them back, despite all outward signs of success. Tackling this issue requires more than just boosting morale—it calls for a deeper understanding of the emotional and mental struggles they face.
Performance anxiety doesn’t discriminate. Even those who’ve climbed to the top of their profession are not immune to the self-doubt that can creep in. It’s the pressure to always maintain perfection, to never fall short, and, more than anything, the fear of being exposed as someone who may not be quite as brilliant as others think. But there's good news: with the right strategies and support, this anxiety can be managed and even turned into an asset. Let’s talk about ways to create environments where top achievers can push through the mental barriers that might otherwise derail their performance.
The Fear Of Falling Short
For high achievers, one of the biggest triggers of performance anxiety is the relentless fear of falling short of expectations—either their own or those of others. They may have set a track record for excelling in all areas of their work, and the very idea of not living up to that past success can leave them paralyzed. This isn't simply a matter of being nervous about failure; it's a deep-rooted fear of disappointing those who believe in their capabilities.
To help them overcome this, it’s essential to normalize the conversation about mistakes. Reframe what failure means. Mistakes should be viewed as learning opportunities, but that’s easier said than done when one has spent a career being defined by their ability to succeed consistently. The key is not to wait until a mistake happens. Instead, foster a culture where ongoing feedback is encouraged, and the concept of failure is redefined to remove its sting.
Dealing With The Internal Critic
There’s no bigger bully than the one that lives inside the mind of a high achiever. The inner critic is constantly whispering about everything that could go wrong, how people are watching, and how even the smallest misstep could lead to disaster. It’s a constant battle between the confident exterior and the internal dialogue that keeps casting doubt.
One way to help is through mindfulness practices. Encouraging top performers to practice mindfulness gives them a tool to pause, observe their thoughts, and detach from the critical inner voice. They can learn to step back from those negative self-assessments and recognize them as just thoughts, not facts. In the process, they can weaken the power of those internal criticisms and start to rebuild a healthier sense of self-worth that isn't tied exclusively to external achievements.
Setting Realistic Standards
The pressure to be the best often means top achievers set unrealistically high standards for themselves. They believe their value is tied to how much they can produce, and the margin for error is slim to none. This all-or-nothing mentality often contributes to an unhealthy work-life balance and increases their vulnerability to burnout.
A practical way to support high performers in this area is by encouraging them to break their work into smaller, manageable goals. This approach serves two purposes. First, it allows for more frequent wins, which can help reduce the pressure they feel to meet a large, daunting goal. Second, it brings focus to incremental progress, shifting attention from a nebulous future outcome to the small, daily steps they can take. Celebrating each small milestone helps alleviate the sense that they’re always chasing something unattainable.
Encouraging a Sense of Control
Another common contributor to performance anxiety is the feeling of being out of control. Even the most competent individuals can experience anxiety when they feel like circumstances are spiraling beyond their grasp. This might stem from workload, changing expectations, or shifting organizational goals that make it hard for them to predict outcomes.
Providing a sense of structure and predictability where possible can ease this anxiety. Even in highly dynamic environments, small things like clear communication, regular check-ins, and giving individuals autonomy in how they approach their tasks can help restore a sense of control. Additionally, tools like time-blocking, prioritization methods, and boundaries around availability can help reduce the overwhelming feeling that often comes from juggling too many responsibilities at once.
Building Emotional Resilience
When we talk about performance anxiety, what we’re really talking about is a lack of emotional resilience. High performers tend to tie their self-worth to their accomplishments, which means that any perceived shortcoming can lead to a disproportionate emotional response. Building resilience, then, is key to managing their anxiety in the long term.
This involves helping them identify when they are approaching burnout and offering strategies to recharge. Sometimes, just reminding them that rest is productive can shift their mindset. Encourage them to set non-negotiable time for themselves, whether that means taking regular breaks during the workday, pursuing hobbies outside of work, or simply unplugging from technology to reset. Resilience isn’t about powering through exhaustion, but learning how to recover in a way that prepares them to face the next challenge head-on.
Addressing the Impostor Syndrome
Performance anxiety is often intertwined with impostor syndrome—the feeling that they’ve somehow tricked everyone into thinking they’re more capable than they are. No matter how much evidence there is of their competence, these individuals can’t shake the feeling that it’s only a matter of time before they’re found out.
Tackling impostor syndrome requires reinforcing a balanced view of self-worth. Achievements should be acknowledged, but it’s also important to highlight the personal qualities and skills that led to those achievements. Remind them that their accomplishments weren’t just lucky breaks; they were the result of hard work, creativity, and resilience. Sometimes, the simple act of having an honest conversation about impostor syndrome can start to chip away at its hold. It helps when they realize they’re not alone—many of their peers feel the same way.
Opening Up Vulnerability
One of the toughest things for high achievers to embrace is vulnerability. To them, vulnerability is synonymous with weakness. But in reality, being open about struggles and uncertainties is a powerful way to humanize leadership and break down performance anxiety. When they allow themselves to be vulnerable, they give others permission to do the same, creating an environment where mutual support is normalized.
Encourage leaders and peers alike to model vulnerability in conversations. This doesn’t mean oversharing; rather, it’s about creating an environment where people can admit they’re having a tough time without fear of judgment. That open dialogue helps demystify the feelings of anxiety that are often tucked away out of shame or fear of seeming less capable.
Wrapping It All Together
When helping top achievers manage performance anxiety, the most important thing is to recognize that anxiety doesn’t make them any less capable or driven. It’s part of their journey, and with the right support, they can learn to navigate it without letting it control them. For managers and leaders, this means being intentional about creating an environment that fosters open communication, emotional resilience, and a healthy relationship with work.
At Dailyhuman, we know that performance anxiety is just one aspect of the larger challenge of mental and emotional resilience. Our Mindset Labs offer tools and frameworks that help people practice the skills they need to stay at their best—without burning out. It’s all about shifting from theory into real-world practice, and that’s where true growth happens.
Comments